A Drop Away from Nothingness
Let me tell you an anecdote. It is a little funny and a little chilling. Above all, it shows how fragile our reputation in specialty coffee is.
Have you heard of the butterfly effect? It helps us think about how even a small difference at the start can, over time, lead to a completely different course of events. Edward Lorenz demonstrated this using weather models, whose long-term changes cannot be predicted accurately when the initial data are even slightly imprecise. The butterfly in the famous metaphor does not mean that its wings literally cause a storm; it shows how a small change can have unpredictable consequences in a system such as the atmosphere.
There will be no butterfly in my anecdote. There will be a fly. And a drop of sweat.
For many years, I judged national championship competitions in various World Coffee Championship disciplines. I remember when and where they took place, but the city, date, and people do not matter here, so I will keep those details confidential. The curious can find them.
One time, I was working as head judge at the World Coffee in Good Spirits Championship. One competitor was giving a great presentation, the judges were having a good time, and the cocktails were receiving very high scores. At one point, an unauthorized “competitor” joined the competition: a big, fat fly.
It landed on the garnish of a drink the competitor was about to serve to one of the judges. I was standing to the side—that is the head judge’s role—and I noticed it right away. So did the photographer, who captured it in a picture. Did the competitor see it?
He did. The garnish was there to decorate the drink, not to be eaten, so he did not have to remake that serving. But he had to keep his cool. The fly started buzzing around his head and his hands. What a stubborn beast!
After the competition, he told me he had thought the fly was going to cause a disaster: it might fall into the drink or the coffee, and he might swallow it while speaking!
He held on. He handled it with a smile, and the judges did not blame him for the fly. He was safe—unless he had served the drink with the fly in it.
He won the competition and went to the World Championship. The fly did not take that chance away from him. Perhaps it would rather drink fruit syrup than sit on a dry piece of apple...
At another competition, a competitor had a great presentation, killer coffees, and beautiful latte art. He had been on stage before. It was the World Barista Championship, and I was judging as head judge. The guy was sweating quite a bit—literally. He even had a clean white towel to wipe the sweat from his temple. He used it from time to time, showing that he cared about hygiene while also trying to avoid... the inevitable.
He is drawing latte art, leaning over the coffee. A thin line of sweat runs across his forehead. A drop pauses at his temple.
Will it fall in? Will it stay put? Will it drop? Will it hold? A lottery.
It did not fall. And he won a place at the World Championship. There, he had the towel again. Much of his preparation was shaped by that drop of sweat which, like the butterfly effect, did not fall—and allowed him to reach the World Championship semifinals.
Have you ever had a fly buzzing around your nose?
Or a drop of sweat in your espresso?